Name: Black Forest Pies & Grinders
Price range: $$

Black Forest Pies & Grinders Information

Tucked along Black Forest Rd, Black Forest Pies & Grinders feels like the kind of place locals quietly treasure and visitors are pleasantly surprised to discover. The location at 11470 Black Forest Rd in Colorado Springs gives it a slightly off-the-beaten-path charm, surrounded by that laid-back, semi-rural atmosphere that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Walking in, there’s an immediate sense of comfort-nothing overly polished, just a welcoming diner vibe with the smell of baked dough and savory fillings hanging in the air.

The menu leans heavily into what they do best: hearty grinders, classic comfort food, and, of course, pies that live up to the name. Their sandwiches are stacked generously, with fresh bread that strikes that perfect balance between soft and chewy. One standout is their Italian grinder, loaded with meats, crisp veggies, and just enough dressing to tie it all together without turning soggy. It’s the kind of meal that feels satisfying without trying too hard to impress. On another visit, the meatball sub held its own, with rich, well-seasoned sauce and tender meatballs that tasted homemade rather than mass-produced.

But the pies are what keep people talking. Whether you go for a fruit pie or something more decadent, there’s a clear attention to detail in the crust alone-flaky, buttery, and not overly sweet. A slice of cherry pie had that ideal balance of tart and sweet, with a filling that didn’t feel overly thickened or artificial. It’s the sort of dessert that feels like it came straight from a family recipe rather than a commercial kitchen.

Service here tends to match the relaxed tone of the place. Staff are friendly and straightforward, quick to offer recommendations if you’re undecided, and attentive without hovering. During busier hours, there can be a bit of a wait, which isn’t surprising given the steady stream of regulars and the limited seating, but it’s rarely frustrating enough to deter a return visit.

Reviews from the local community often highlight the consistency, which is something that’s easy to overlook until you’ve been a few times yourself. The food doesn’t fluctuate wildly, and the atmosphere stays reliably casual and welcoming. While it may not have the polished presentation of a downtown hotspot, it delivers where it counts-good food, generous portions, and a genuine neighborhood feel that’s increasingly hard to find.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Great value! Salads at $3, fries $1.99. Nice folks, no tip needed as you get your food. Had salad, fries and have had a grinder. All great and made fresh.

Spontaneously stopped by for lunch with my family and was NOT disappointed. The food was amazing. We all ordered different stuff and it was all delicious and fresh. My favorite was the Stromboli!! Only downside we had was the young kid that took our order. He didn't greet us when we came in at all and was not friendly. It was our first time in so we had a few questions and he seemed bothered and didn't want to help or talk to us. The other older gentleman working definitely made up for him though. He was very kind and genuine he delivered our food and checked in a few times. Inside dining is older n little run down but overall would definitely recommend and would go back!

There is a sit in eating area, but we picked up our food. It was great and large. The people at the counter were very nice. Well worth the money and good food.

Awesome pizza! Great flavor and the crust so good! Not soggy like many others. The restaurant in Black Forest is cozy but with great character. The staff always friendly. Great place to eat or take out. I couldn't take a picture with the full pie :) so hungry!!!

I ordered an 18in pan crust pizza online to be delivered to my home, along with a house salad and cheesy garlic bread. The delivery was on time, delivered by a really kind young lady. The pizza was fantastic, garlic bread and marinara delicious and the salad fresh. My family will be ordering from them again! I forgot to get a picture before we dug in because it smelled so good!

Not to be confused with a dessert pie, it's PIZZA Pie they serve! Their menu is extensive, the place is über clean and staff is laid back & friendly. While you wait for your homemade, made-to-order pizza pie or grinders you can play trivia pursuit. One of the greatest games of all time. Conveniently located, bring the kids as is!

Ordered online for pick up. Ordered large New York thin. It definitely was not New York thin, have ordered from here multiple times so I know the crust was thicker than I’m used to. But the pizza was still good just prefer way less dough!

Well we saw the great reviews so we thought we'd check it out while we where around black forest. Quite frankly we really liked it a lot. Plus very good service and really great food. We got the calzone and the Philly cheesesteak both are really good. I took some pictures of both of them.Thought they need to have a few more photos so people can what the food looks like. I know that always helps me when checking out new places to try out.

Black Forest Pies & Grinders